Coin Collector’s Dream: 7 More $1,200+ Rare Gems

6 Min Read

For enthusiasts of coin collecting, the excitement of uncovering a rare treasure is unparalleled.

The realm of numismatics is brimming with such coveted finds, some fetching prices exceeding $1,200 due to their rarity, historical importance, and condition.


This article explores seven more of these highly sought-after coins, each a prized discovery for serious collectors.

1849 Coronet Head Gold Double Eagle

The 1849 Coronet Head Gold Double Eagle holds a special place in the annals of numismatic history.

Minted during the California Gold Rush, this coin represents the inaugural production of $20 gold pieces by the United States Mint.

Its scarcity is emphasized by its limited production; only a handful of specimens are known to exist today.

Collectors value this coin not only for its rarity but also for its role in shaping U.S. monetary history.

In pristine condition, its value can easily surpass the $1,200 threshold, with prices reaching into the millions for exceptional examples.

1916-D Mercury Dime

The 1916-D Mercury Dime stands as a key rarity within the Mercury Dime series. With a mintage of just over 264,000, it holds the lowest production figure among all Mercury Dimes.

This coin is highly coveted by collectors, particularly in superior grades where its scarcity becomes even more pronounced.

The allure of the 1916-D lies in its combination of age, aesthetic appeal, and rarity.

In uncirculated condition, it can command well over $1,200, with top-tier specimens fetching significantly higher prices.

1937-D 3-Legged Buffalo Nickel

This distinctive variety of the Buffalo Nickel arose from a minting error, resulting in the inadvertent removal of the buffalo’s front leg from the die.

The 1937-D 3-Legged Buffalo Nickel is a favorite among collectors for its peculiar nature and the story behind its creation.

Despite its initial large mintage, the number of surviving 3-legged varieties is considerably lower, rendering it a rare find.

In decent condition, this coin easily exceeds the $1,200 mark, particularly if it retains sharp details and minimal wear.

1794 Flowing Hair Silver Dollar

The 1794 Flowing Hair Silver Dollar holds the distinction of being one of the earliest silver dollars minted in the United States.

Its historical significance, combined with its age and scarcity, renders it a highly prized item.

With only a limited quantity minted and even fewer surviving in good condition, this coin has attained legendary status in the realm of numismatics.

Well-preserved examples can fetch astronomical prices, far surpassing the $1,200 mark.

1893-S Morgan Silver Dollar

Revered as the pinnacle of the Morgan Dollar series, the 1893-S boasts the lowest mintage of the entire series, with only 100,000 coins struck.

Its rarity is further compounded by the extensive circulation of many examples, leaving few in high grades.

For Morgan Dollar aficionados, the 1893-S is a holy grail, and its value reflects this esteemed status.

Even in lower grades, this coin can command prices well over $1,200, with mint-condition specimens being particularly sought after.

1955 Double Die Lincoln Cent

The 1955 Double Die Lincoln Cent ranks among the most renowned error coins in American numismatic history.

Due to misalignment during the minting process, these cents display noticeably doubled inscriptions and dates.

While the total mintage remains unknown, their rarity is undeniable. Collectors prize this coin for its error and the clarity of the doubling.

In top grades, it can easily surpass the $1,200 mark, with pristine examples holding significantly greater value.

2000-P Sacagawea Dollar “Cheerios”

The 2000-P Sacagawea Dollar, famously known as the “Cheerios” dollar, represents a modern rarity.

These coins, distributed as a promotion in Cheerios cereal boxes, feature a distinct tail feather detail different from regular issues.

With only 5,500 distributed in this manner, they are highly sought after by collectors.

In mint condition, these coins can fetch well over $1,200, appealing to both contemporary coin enthusiasts and those intrigued by unique promotional items.


In conclusion, the realm of coin collecting teems with rare and valuable specimens, each imbued with its own narrative and allure.

From historical treasures like the 1794 Flowing Hair Silver Dollar to modern curiosities like the “Cheerios” Sacagawea Dollar, these coins transcend mere monetary value; they embody history, artistry, and cultural significance.

For collectors, the pursuit of these elusive treasures is more than a pastime—it is a fervent passion fueled by the thrill of discovery and an appreciation for their intrinsic and historical importance.

Share This Article
Leave a comment